More coursework: 1 - A | B | C | D | E | F | G | H | I - J | K - L | M | N - O | P - S | T | U - Y

A comparison of the magic in the rocking horse winner and a very old man with

A Comparison of the Magic in "The Rocking-Horse Winner" and "A Very Old Man With

Enormous Wings"

Magic arises out of the two main characters of D.H. Lawrence's "The

Rocking-Horse Winner" and Gabriel Garcia Marquez. Paul, in the first story,

pulls out higher forces to help him decide who the winner of the next horse race

will be. In the Marquez story, a nameless and elderly angel lands on earth to

experience first hand the human behavior he strives to correct. The magic in

the air gives these stories a feeling of suspense. They are horrifying, if not

in the Stephen King horror genre. These tales encompass an undeniable amount of

magic, faith, greed, vindication and misunderstanding.

Pelayo and Elisenda, in the Garcia Marquez yarn, find the soul retriever

on his way to take their child to heaven, or so it is thought. The magical

angel's identity had to be discovered by a neighbor of the couple because they

didn't think that an angel could wind up on their land. Who would think of an

angel landing? Meanwhile, Paul doesn't show when he discovers the magical power

of the rocking horse he received as a gift one year. He does ride it often as

Lawrence describes. The stories are bound by the fact that the magical things

they discover are unbelievable at best. They often criticize Paul for his

affection for a horse he should have outgrown long ago. No one would believe

that the rocking-horse essentially talked to him. Although the characters in "A

Very Old Man with Enormous Wings" believe that an angel is in their presence,

they have no idea what to do with him. No one had ever dealt with a spirit on

this level before.

As he rocked back and forth on his rocking horse, Paul had faith in

finding the winner of the next horse race. For some reason they could not

explain, Paul's uncle and Bassett had faith in him to pick it. They kept making

money on the young boy with faith. The boy, whose parents had no luck, also had

the faith that they did not have. Sadly, his faith killed him. He wanted so

much to rid the house of the voices he heard that he drove himself to death from

the intense pressure he placed upon himself. When he died, he killed the voices

as the spiritual world claimed the only member of the family with luck.

"A Very Old Man with Enormous Wings" shows that the people in this small

fan can have some level of faith without directly showing it. Although Pelayo

and Elisenda lock up the angel to display him, they still believe he is an angel

and cannot kill him when another offers this. They don't have the heart to club

the old man to death, though he may be an inconvenience at first. Father

Gonzaga doesn't necessarily believe in the angel, but the townspeople and

tourists do. They wish for things even when others before them don't have their

miracles exactly met.

It is hinted in the Lawrence story that Paul may have lived if he hadn't

been so greedy. He wasn't full of greed like his parents, but the mysterious

voices of the house drove him to greed to rid the house of them. To start with,

Mother and Father in this modern fairy tale are downright rapacious. Mother has

an especially insatiable wallet. Although her husband makes good money, she

must have the finer things in life such as servants and the like. They pass on

the ever present desire for more materialistic items to Paul. He wants to gain

the love of his mother and decides that using his luck to earn money is the way

to do it.

It is the greed of Pelayo and Elisenda that wind up saving the life of

the elderly angel. They give him a chance to rest and start anew by the couple

putting him on display as a sort of circus freak. Sadly enough this translates

over to modern sitings of crucifix marked men. Many religious fanatics have to

travel wide and far to see proof of their faith just like in the story. The

fact that the poor couple makes money off the angel could be a testament to him

being their guardian angel as opposed to the harbinger of death to their child.

They continue to make money off this freak of nature until another shows up.

The spider girl is just another form of greed in this story. The actual freak

is probably just a costumed human trying to make money off people's stupidity.

Flaws are obvious in the main characters of each of these two stories.

In "The Rocking- Horse Winner" Paul has the flaw of emulating his parents'

footsteps. Because they set the example always to want more money, taking on

their greed flaws him. In Garcia Marquez's tale, the simple couple have greed

on their mind. When they are unable to make money, off what should be a

blessing, they find him an annoyance. They share this greed in both stories and

this is an undeniable flaw.

Another characteristic that joins these two stories is vindication. In

the Lawrence tale, Paul gets two sorts of vindication. First, he proves to his

mother, the nonbelieiver, that he is truly lucky. The curse is not on every

member of the family is the unspoken statement he makes to his mother. This

also makes him think in his last few moments that he has also attained the

obviously missing love of his mother. Although this is probably not true since

his mother is such a greedy character, seemingly incapable of love, at least

Paul thinks that he has rectified a horrible relationship between mother and son.

Secondly, they vindicate him in an ironic way. His death is part of his life's

justification. He escapes an unhappy situation. As a blessing to his family,

he earns a ton of money for his uncle, Bassett and his family (whom the money

should go to upon his death). He helps them out and then gets out of the bad

situation of being stuck in such a greedy, luckless family through death.

The angel also has a two-part vindication. While entrapped by his own

disabilities in the chicken coop, he gets to poke fun at the naive people

desperately looking for miracles by granting "consolation miracles" to his

customers. These pranks entertained him while he was stuck recovering in an

animal's residence that was like a miniature circus tent. After he finally

recovered with dawn of spring, he took to flight. He certainly wouldn't take

the child with him for fear of staying any longer. He escaped the place that

did nothing but use him to move on to provide miracles to people who were worth


Lastly, intertwined in these two stories is a misunderstanding of the

respective phenomenons. The uncle and Basset are interested mostly in winning

money off the boy's talent. Uncle Oscar does appear to have some concern for

the boy having fun and appears to find it engaging that the young boy is

interested in a hobby of his. Bassett also seems to enjoy the boy's company,

but it certainly apparent after the first few wins that both are mostly using

Paul to earn money on his luck. They don't understand the mostly self-inflicted

need to be lucky that Paul feels. He wants to be lucky to win the love of not

just his mother, but also Oscar, Bassett and the family in general. He hides

the fact that riding his wooden rocking-horse is the key to his winning and so

Oscar and Bassett have little idea of what's going on. Even at his final ride,

the two who share in his lucky picks assume that he got sick under normal

circumstances. They don't fathom to guess that he was trying to defeat the

curse of misfortune his family seemed to have an attraction to and the voices in

the house which constantly pointed this fact. Of course, they thought he simply

played to earn money and enjoy a hobby.

From beginning to end, "A Very Old Man with Enormous Wings" shows how

ignorant the characters are of the truth in the story. Even at first Pelayo and

Elisenda can't figure out that their discovery is an angel. It even took the

main characters awhile to discover that they could make much money off their

find. By the end of the anecdote, the angel has become such an inconvenience

that Elisenda was overjoyed to seem him recover and leave. Instead of realizing

the blessings the elderly angel brought (apparently saving the child's life and

creating an extra income for the couple for a couple weeks), she found him to be

a pest.

These fantastical stories have many similar messages and characteristics

although each of them is individual. They have the same goal of exploring the

misunderstood and magical. These qualities affect the reader. The story

becomes engaging as the reader joins the characters in attempting to find out

the mysteries behind many of the actions. The characters get involved in the

unbelievable while they try to understand things that some people simply cannot

grasp in their minds. All of the characters in both tales are ignorant and

naive, but this is not to say that they are stupid. They tragically cannot

understand what they have with the little bit of evidence they are provided.

Upon realizing that they cannot explain the unexplainable, they attempt to come

with answers where the are none.

Thus when magic, faith, greed, vindication and misunderstanding come

together they form two different stories. The narratives by two authors, D.H.

Lawrence and Gabriel Garcia Marquez of completely different backgrounds come

through with a common message. The spiritual and magical world can help and

hurt humans so always understand what it is one is getting into. They continue

to point out that people should never let greed get the best of them because

they will miss the main point. "The Old Man with Enormous Wings" and "The

Rocking-Horse Winner" offer different versions of the same idea. The reader

easily receives both of their messages and certain to be forgiving of their main

character's ignorance and naivety.

About this resource

This coursework was submitted to us by a student in order to help you with your studies.

Search our content:

  • Download this page
  • Print this page
  • Search again

  • Word count:

    This page has approximately words.



    If you use part of this page in your own work, you need to provide a citation, as follows:

    Essay UK, A Comparison Of The Magic In The Rocking Horse Winner And A Very Old Man Wit. Available from: <> [26-05-20].

    More information:

    If you are the original author of this content and no longer wish to have it published on our website then please click on the link below to request removal: