More coursework: 1 - A | B | C | D | E | F | G | H | I - J | K - L | M | N - O | P - S | T | U - Y

Import substitution

Import Substitution

Describe import substitution (Inward looking) developmental strategy, clearly

outlining the differences between the first and second stage. Assess its

effectiveness in promoting economic development. Compare inward looking and

outward looking strategies and discuss the assertion that the latter is superior.

The First Stage of Import Substitution:

All present day industrial and developing countries protect their

manufacturing industries for the domestic markets. While the industrial

countries of today rely primarily upon the usage of relatively low tariffs,

developing countries apply high tariffs or quantitative restrictions which

either limit or completely exclude competition from their imports. Protection

like that - high protection - discriminates against exports through the

explicit/implicit taxation of the export activities.

Explicit taxation can take the form of export taxes whereas implicit

taxation occurs as a result of the effects of protection on the exchange rate.

As your protection level increases, your exchange rate level will decrease in

order to ensure the necessary equilibrium of the balance of payments and the

lower the amount of domestic currency exporters receive per unit of foreign

exchange earned.

There is no need for high protection at the first stage of import

substitution in the replacement of the imports of non-durable consumer goods

(clothing, shoes, household goods, textile fabrics, leather, wood and other

types of inputs) since these commodities exist in the developing countries that

are at the initial frontier of industrialization.

The commodities I mentioned are intensive in unskilled labor, the scale

of output is relatively low, and costs do not rise substantially at lower output

levels. The production of the commodities do not involve the use of

sophisticated technology or highly educated workers and suppliers for parts,

components, materials and accessories are not necessary for highly efficient


An argument for infant industry protection and promotion is made for the

"easy" stage, that being the first stage of import substitution because even

though the domestic production of the commodities generates external economies

in the form of labor training, entrepreneurial development and the spread of

technology, there is a viable argument for infant industry protection because

without the shielding from larger, more sophisticated companies, these infant

industries will be crushed and overwhelmed by exceeding costs, non-

competitiveness due to the lack of highly skilled laborers and the simple fact

that these infant industries are technologically incompetent.

The Second Stage of Import Substitution:

I see the first stage of import substitution as a temporary requirement

because the domestic production rises since it not only provides for increases

in consumption but it also replaces imports. The rate of this growth however

will decline as soon as the process of import substitution is completed.

The maintaining of these high industrial growth rates necessitates the

turning to the exportation of manufactured goods or moving to second stage

import substitution.

Second stage import substitution involves the replacement of

intermediate goods and consumer durables by domestic production. These

intermediate goods are highly capital intensive and are subject to important

economies of scale. The margin of processing is very small and organizational

and technical inefficiencies may contribute to high costs.

Due to the scarcity of physical and human capital in developing

countries that complete the first stage of import substitution, they tend to be

at a disadvantage in the manufacture if highly physical capital intensive

intermediate goods and skill intensive producer and consumer durables. By

limiting the scope for the exploitation of economies of scale, the relatively

small size of their national markets also contributes to high domestic costs in

these countries.

Source: Essay UK -

About this resource

This coursework was submitted to us by a student in order to help you with your studies.

Search our content:

  • Download this page
  • Print this page
  • Search again

  • Word count:

    This page has approximately words.



    If you use part of this page in your own work, you need to provide a citation, as follows:

    Essay UK, Import Substitution. Available from: <> [06-06-20].

    More information:

    If you are the original author of this content and no longer wish to have it published on our website then please click on the link below to request removal: